Top of San Antonio

San Antonio / Guides / Steak in New Braunfels
The Guide · Steak in New Braunfels

Best Steak in New Braunfels (2026)

Seven restaurants across San Antonio. Compare neighborhoods, price tiers and what to order, then read the full reviews.

Yvette Cisneros
By Yvette Cisneros Dining Trends Editor · Updated October 2026 · How the score is built
Best Steak in New Braunfels (2026)
THE SAN ANTONIO DINING GUIDES 7 restaurants
Compare all 7 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Gristmill River Restaurant & BarNew Braunfels$$6.3Chicken Fried Steak
02 Root Cellar CafeNew Braunfels$$5.5Loaded Breakfast Skillet
03 Cody's RestaurantNew Braunfels5.4Pan-Seared Salmon
04 The Mess AroundNew Braunfels$5.3Club Sandwich
05 Black Bear DinerNew Braunfels$$5.1Bear Claw Pancakes
06 Marco Polo Philly CheesesteaksNew Braunfels$$5.4Classic Philly Cheesesteak
07 Saltgrass Steak HouseNew Braunfels5.1Saltgrass Sirloin

7 restaurants · In guide order

1 Gristmill River Restaurant & Bar Yelp

Gristmill River Restaurant & Bar

American · New Braunfels · $$ · № 32 on the List
Insider Score6.3

The Gristmill sits in the brick ruins of an 1878 cotton gin below the Gruene water tower, and the history is the point as much as the plate. The chicken fried steak is the call here, alongside BBQ ribs and grilled catfish. The room turns tables on weekend evenings at a steady pace, and the outdoor decks over the Guadalupe make it a natural for family dinners that want scenery with their supper.

What to orderChicken Fried SteakBBQ RibsGrilled Catfish Restaurant Reservations Call Directions
Full review & visiting detailsRead the full review & visiting details

Texas Comfort in a Historic Gruene Mill

Chicken Fried Steak

The chicken fried steak is the anchor of a menu rooted in Texas roadhouse tradition, served inside the brick ruins of an 1878 cotton gin above the Guadalupe River.

BBQ Ribs

The BBQ ribs carry the smoke-and-char profile that draws the Hill Country crowd back to this Gruene landmark, built into the old boiler room of a 19th-century cotton gin.

Grilled Catfish

Grilled catfish is the lighter alternative on a menu heavy with Texas beef, a river-country standard that fits the Guadalupe-side setting.

The Gristmill earns its place on the strength of setting and Texas-comfort cooking, housed in the bones of a 19th-century cotton gin in the historic Gruene district of New Braunfels. The building does half the work, its weathered timber and riverside terraces giving the room a sense of place that no new construction can fake, and the kitchen meets it with food built for the same unpretentious crowd. Chicken fried steak is the benchmark order, a broad, hand-breaded cutlet under cream gravy that defines the genre, while the barbecue ribs lean into the smoke-and-sauce tradition the Hill Country expects. Grilled catfish rounds out the range for anyone wanting something off the fryer, and the menu stays anchored in the American-Texan staples that travel well with a long table and a pitcher.

The draw is the experience as much as any single plate: shaded outdoor seating above the Guadalupe, a steady weekend churn of families and tourists drawn by the adjacent dance hall, and a pace that handles a crowd without losing its footing. This is special-occasion dining in the Texas sense, where the occasion is a Sunday with relatives or a stop after a float down the river rather than a tasting menu. Prices stay accessible, which keeps the room democratic and full. New Braunfels has its share of polished newcomers, and the Gristmill holds its ground by being exactly what it has long been, a dependable Texas kitchen in a setting locals bring out-of-town guests to see.

The wurst plate and fried seafood widen the options for a mixed table. For scenic, generous, family-minded Texas comfort food with real history under the floorboards, it remains a Gruene anchor.

Map showing Gristmill River Restaurant & Bar© OpenStreetMap
HoursMon - Thu: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address1287 Gruene Rd New Braunfels
TX 78130
Insider tip

Aim for a shaded terrace table above the Guadalupe and pair the chicken fried steak with the ribs; weekends draw heavy crowds from the neighboring dance hall, so timing helps.

2 Root Cellar Cafe Yelp

Root Cellar Cafe

Brunch · New Braunfels · $$
Insider Score5.5

Root Cellar's steak entry is the Country Fried Steak Benedict, a breakfast-hour move that puts the classic in brunch territory. The kitchen also runs a loaded breakfast skillet and Bananas Foster French toast worth the detour. Asparagus fries show up as a shareable starter. The room draws families and weekend crowds, runs a full-service floor, and operates at the casual end of the New Braunfels brunch scene.

What to orderLoaded Breakfast SkilletBanana Foster French ToastCountry Fried Steak Benedict Call Directions Scored from the full review record 1090 I-35BL New Braunfels, TX 78130 · (830) 632-5114
3 Cody's Restaurant Yelp

Cody's Restaurant

New American · New Braunfels
Insider Score5.4

Cody's is the special-occasion room in the New Braunfels rotation: a ribeye on the menu, craft cocktails at the bar, and a Saturday happy hour that brings in the pre-dinner crowd. The price point runs higher than most of the corridor, and diners flag it as worth the return. Pan-seared salmon rounds out the proteins for tables that split. Full-service, reservations-friendly, and the closest thing in town to an expense-account dinner.

What to orderPan-Seared SalmonRibeye SteakCraft Cocktail Selection Call Directions Scored from the full review record 188 S Castell Ave New Braunfels, TX 78130 · (830) 609-9194
4 The Mess Around Yelp

The Mess Around

Sandwiches · New Braunfels · $
Insider Score5.3

The steak here is a Philly cheesesteak, not a Texas ribeye, but it earns its place on a list serving river-day crowds who want something quick and satisfying. The patio does steady work, service runs efficiently, and the kitchen takes its time. A ham and cheese croissant and grilled chicken sandwich round out the counter-service lineup. Order, grab a spot outside, and give it a few minutes.

What to orderClub SandwichPhilly CheesesteakGrilled Chicken Sandwich Call Directions Scored from the full review record 471 Main Plz Ste A New Braunfels, TX 78130 · (830) 620-7200
5 Black Bear Diner Yelp

Black Bear Diner

Diners · New Braunfels · $$
Insider Score5.1

Black Bear Diner is a national chain, and the New Braunfels location operates with the chain's signature country-diner format: big portions, Bear Claw pancakes, a loaded country omelet, and chicken fried steak as the anchor plate. The room runs family-friendly from early morning. Service has been a mixed point in the record, with some waits running long at midday. Come for breakfast or an early lunch to avoid the bottleneck.

What to orderBear Claw PancakesChicken Fried SteakLoaded Country Omelet Call Directions Scored from the full review record 4817 I-35 N New Braunfels, TX 78130 · (830) 608-9395
6 Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks Yelp

Marco Polo Philly Cheesesteaks

Sandwiches · New Braunfels · $$
Insider Score5.4

Marco Polo makes its Philly cheesesteak to order: fresh-cooked, locally owned, and built with the kind of care that earns a pre-river ritual for regulars. The classic comes standard, and the kitchen also does a version loaded with mushrooms, onions, and peppers. The Italian meatball sub and chicken parmigiana sandwich round out the menu. Counter-service, casual, and fast enough to fit a river day.

What to orderClassic Philly CheesesteakItalian Meatball SubChicken Parmigiana Sandwich Call Directions Scored from the full review record 961 N Business 35 New Braunfels, TX 78130 · (830) 627-9587
7 Saltgrass Steak House Yelp

Saltgrass Steak House

Seafood · New Braunfels
Insider Score5.1

Saltgrass is a Texas-based chain, and the New Braunfels location draws regulars who treat it as a reliable special-occasion room, including Thanksgiving dinner crowds who come back year after year. The Saltgrass Sirloin and grilled Gulf red snapper anchor the menu alongside a chicken fried steak. Service consistently gets high marks. Portion size relative to the price point draws some pushback, but the waitstaff more than holds the room together.

What to orderSaltgrass SirloinGrilled Gulf Red SnapperChicken Fried Steak Call Directions Scored from the full review record 744 Interstate 35 North Frontage Rd New Braunfels, TX 78130 · (830) 318-2747
What to know before choosing a restaurant

Best Steak in New Braunfels: 1. Gristmill River Restaurant & Bar · 2. Root Cellar Cafe · 3. Cody's Restaurant · 4. The Mess Around · 5. Black Bear Diner. Addresses, prices and what to order.

New Braunfels runs on river days and Hill Country hospitality, and its steak options span a lot of ground: a century-old cotton gin ruin above the Guadalupe, a date-night room with craft cocktails, a chain that draws Thanksgiving regulars, and a breakfast counter that sneaks a country fried steak into a Benedict. This guide covers the steaks and steak-adjacent plates worth knowing, from a quick Philly cheesesteak before the tubes hit the water to a proper ribeye after.

Frequently asked

Where can I find the best steak near me in New Braunfels?
Cody's Restaurant is the top full-service steak option in New Braunfels, with a ribeye and craft cocktails in an upscale room suited for date nights and special occasions. Saltgrass Steak House is the reliable chain pick with a Texas sirloin and consistent service. The Gristmill in Gruene adds a historic setting above the Guadalupe if you want scenery with your meal. All three appear in this guide, ranked by the Insider Score. No restaurant pays to be listed.
Is the Gristmill good for families?
Yes. The Gristmill's outdoor decks over the Guadalupe River are a natural fit for family dinners, and the menu covers chicken fried steak, BBQ ribs, and grilled catfish at a mid-range price. The room turns tables steadily on weekend evenings, so waits are generally manageable.
Does New Braunfels have a nice steakhouse for a special occasion?
Cody's Restaurant is the strongest option for a special-occasion dinner in New Braunfels. The ribeye, craft cocktail program, and full-service floor put it in the upscale tier for the corridor. It runs on the pricier side, which diners note, but repeat visits are common. The Insider Score on each listing reflects the full pattern of the public record, and no restaurant pays for placement.
What is the Insider Score and how are these restaurants chosen?
The Insider Score is Top of San Antonio's ranking system, calculated from public review data weighted for quality and recency. The guides are editorial, not paid placements. No restaurant pays to appear or to rank higher. The seven picks here represent the range of steak and steak-adjacent options in New Braunfels, from a Philly cheesesteak counter to a full-service ribeye room.
ƒ

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Yvette Cisneros
Dining Trends Editor

Yvette tracks the new San Antonio: the openings, the chefs just landing, the formats changing how the city eats. She writes the trend pieces and gets there before the line forms.

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.

Get the Tip Sheet →