Best Pizza in New Braunfels (2026)

The beer program is the draw that gets people in the door, but the wood-fired pepperoni pizza is what keeps them at the table. New York and Detroit-style pies both land consistently, and the wings and fries hold their own alongside the lineup. Live music runs on weekends, so the room gets loud and social. Order at the counter, grab a brew, and settle in for the kind of casual evening New Braunfels does well.

Noli's Vite runs a full Italian menu and leans into the classics. The margherita pizza is the anchor, but the pasta side earns real attention: spaghetti alla puttanesca comes in a solid portion, and the eggplant dishes hold their own. Complimentary garlic knot rolls arrive at the table before you even figure out what you're ordering. Service runs attentive here, and the menu is broad enough to keep the whole family occupied.

Bootleggers leans into a lively, bar-forward room with TVs, a pool table, and enough energy to make it a natural group spot. The wings are the consistent standout, coming out crispy every visit. The craft cocktail list fits the Prohibition-era concept without feeling gimmicky. This is a pizza parlor that doubles as a neighborhood bar, and it handles both roles without either one suffering.

New York Pizza Pub keeps the concept simple: big New York-style slices, a meat lovers supreme that earns its name, and a chicken parm calzone worth the detour. The pub has a long track record in New Braunfels, and regulars will tell you the pepperoni pie is the reason they keep returning. Online ordering is available for pickup, which helps on busy nights when the room fills up fast.

Infernos sits close to Gruene and draws a crowd that comes specifically for the wood-fired margherita. The oven delivers on the crust: thin, blistered, and built with fresh ingredients. Half-and-half orders are accommodated without issue, making it easy to sample the menu. The stromboli is worth adding to the order, and the smoked wings fit right alongside the pizza. A consistent stop for anyone making the Gruene day-trip.

Di's runs as a to-go operation, so there is no dining room to speak of, but the pizza travels well. Deliveries arrive hot, and the build-your-own setup lets the order go exactly where you want it. The pepperoni is the straightforward pick, and the Caesar salad rounds out a simple meal. For a family that wants good pizza at home without the River Walk markup, Di's is the practical call in New Braunfels.

Crust runs a clean, modern operation with pepperoni using cup-and-char style as the signature move. The margherita is a reliable baseline, and the veggie and kids' cheese pies handle the table without fuss. The room accommodates events and group orders, and the staff earns consistent praise for how they handle larger parties. For a family that wants a no-drama pizza night in a tidy setting, Crust delivers that consistently.

Above Ground Pizza carries the standard lineup: margherita, pepperoni and Italian sausage, and Caesar salad to round the order out. The menu covers the expected ground for a casual pizza spot, and the kitchen runs a full sit-down format. Families and groups make up the regular crowd. For a straightforward pizza night in New Braunfels without much fuss over the menu, it fills the role.

Villanova's is pickup-only, and regulars who make the trip to New Braunfels specifically plan the stop around it. The supreme pizza is the consistent order, and the buffalo wings run a solid supporting role. Service moves quickly, which matters when you are picking up on the way to the river or the park. The no-delivery model has not slowed the word-of-mouth on this one among locals who know the pie.

Mattenga's is a straightforward family pizza spot running a full menu of classics: supreme pie, buffalo wings, and Caesar salad cover the table without much debate. The kitchen handles to-go orders alongside dine-in, and the antipasto salad makes a capable starter. The room is relaxed and the format is simple. For a low-key pizza night in New Braunfels with no surprises in either direction, it fits the occasion.

Stouts Pizza draws repeat visitors specifically for the specialty pies, with the wine country pizza pulling regulars back on its own. The house stout has flavor worth noting alongside the pizza order. The dough runs on the lighter side for those who prefer it that way. Parking is workable once you know the lot. The room operates as a classic pizza parlor, and the specialty menu is the reason to look past the standard order here.

DoubleDave's is the workhorse pick in New Braunfels: pepperoni rolls are the signature move and the reason regulars come back between the bigger pizza orders. The supreme pizza and Italian sandwich round out the menu without overcomplicating it. The dining room stays clean and the food comes out hot. For families who want reliable, fast pizza in a no-fuss setting, DoubleDave's fills that lane consistently.